Child abduction refers to taking a child away from their parent
without a claim of right, according to
California Penal Code Section 278
.
However, there may be instances where a person with a legal
custody right to a child may unlawfully interfere with another
parent’s custody or visitation rights, a case which is also
commonly called child detention.
To prove that someone committed this offense, you should be able
to prove the following:
-
The defendant maliciously took, enticed, kept, withheld or
concealed the child
-
The child was under the age of 18
-
In doing so, the defendant maliciously deprived the lawful
custodian of their right to custody or lawful right to
visitation.
According to all child abduction cases, it does not matter
whether the child resisted or consented to the defendant’s
actions. A custody order obtained after the child’s abduction
can not be a defense to the charges of child abduction by
depriving custody or visitation. Most child abduction is often
carried out by parents, relatives, in-laws, grandparents, and
family members who have no legal rights to custody or visitation
of the child. A parent who takes the child away before any court
order is issued is also subject to child abduction because
parents have equal custody rights in the absence of a court order.
To demonstrate child abduction by way of an example, suppose
there is a father with visitation rights every weekend. One
weekend, when the father spots bruises on his child, he refuses
to return the child to the other parent, suspecting that the
other parent’s new partner might be hurting the child. In this
scenario, the father would not be charged with child
abduction/violating custody rights because his intentions were
not malicious. Instead, he had legitimate concerns for his
son’s safety. However, the father has the legal authority to
report the matter within 10 days to the proper authorities under
California Penal Code Section 278.7 PC.
In another example, a father is granted weekend visitation
rights to his young boy. At the end of the weekend, the boy
expresses the desire to stay one more day with his father, and
the father relents. Thus the boy stays one extra night. Now,
the father is liable to be charged under California Penal Code
Section 278.5 PC with child abduction because he violated the
visitation order.
You must make sure that child abduction is not confused with
kidnapping. Kidnapping under
California Penal Code Section 207 PC
is a serious violent crime offense that involves the holding,
taking, or detention of another person by force or by instilling
fear and moving the other person a substantial distance by
using force or fear. The kidnapping takes the form of aggravated
kidnapping if the person kidnapped was a minor under 14 years
of age.